UPDATE: Congratulations to the 1985 adaptation of Anne of Green Gables. You (and your fans) are the winner of our 2023 Close Reads literary bracket. We will be doing a watch along episode soon so be on the look out for news about that!
Oh how to choose?!?! I love both of these so much! Going with P&P because the book and movie have been a huge delight for me and my dad. We are always quoting lines from it to each other.
I know I'm in the minority but i just don't love the P&P 95 adaptation, it just doesn't have the vibes right!! But man oh man does the AOGG get the vibes right. All that to say I'm voting based on...vibes.
100% correct! I do not swear by this P&P either and I honestly think it should have been eliminated many rounds ago 😂 But this Anne adaptation is just about perfect as adaptations go, not to mention completely delightful to watch too.
This was my take too. If I had to vote on which is the better *book* it would be P&P for sure. But man, does the AoGG movie adaptation nail it from start to finish! It’s just so delightful.
I can't do it. I have to get so nit-picky about aspects of each and I don't know what actually makes a great adaptation.
I ended up phoning a friend; I'm letting my mom make the choice.
Nearly impossible decision... but I think Anne is the better adaptation... or is it P&P? What to do?!
Oh how to choose?!?! I love both of these so much! Going with P&P because the book and movie have been a huge delight for me and my dad. We are always quoting lines from it to each other.
Vegas really had this bracket down. And by Vegas, I mean, David.
Are you KIDDING me??? All these great adaptations and it boils down to this???
Ugggh!! I was really hoping for an LOTR vs. The Muppets matchup or something similar. Oh well!
This has been quite an entertaining March Madness! Thanks for all the hard work y’all put into it. If nothing else, it was fun!
I just want to experience Heidi loving on Anne of Green Gables 😁
This is such a lame matchup that I’m just going to abstain 😂 But this was fun while it lasted, thanks to David and the gang for putting it together!
🤯
I know I'm in the minority but i just don't love the P&P 95 adaptation, it just doesn't have the vibes right!! But man oh man does the AOGG get the vibes right. All that to say I'm voting based on...vibes.
100% correct! I do not swear by this P&P either and I honestly think it should have been eliminated many rounds ago 😂 But this Anne adaptation is just about perfect as adaptations go, not to mention completely delightful to watch too.
Is there any other way to vote, Hannah?!?!?
This was my take too. If I had to vote on which is the better *book* it would be P&P for sure. But man, does the AoGG movie adaptation nail it from start to finish! It’s just so delightful.
100% with you!
Correct take haha
😭😭😭😭
I know I did this to myself but...oof..,,