7 Comments
founding

I don’t think the characters change at all. It’s even hard to imagine that seven years pass by. So when Pearl is transformed by her Father’s recognition, it’s very sudden and anticlimactic (maybe?).

Expand full comment
founding

... Hester is literally still wearing the scarlet letter, doing what she was doing in the same place. It’s the same objective correlative which Dimmesdale speaks of when he’s telling Hester of their never having really been able to be together on this side of heaven. The already-but-not-yet. Which funnily enough reminds me of Puritanism, in a good way.

Expand full comment

I'm curious to hear more from Heidi talking about Hester's character. I missed the compelling nature of Hester's character.

Expand full comment

I also want to see David's list of books which are good in both ideas and plot.

Expand full comment

Is this where we post questions for the Q&A episode? If so, I'm curious about what Karen believes are the morals of the book. She noted one, that hidden guilt kills, but alluded to there being more.

Expand full comment

David’s comment about Dostoevsky incorporating ideas and story reminded me of Solzhenitsyn’s Cancer Ward—also excellently done. Could this be a strength of those Russians?

Expand full comment

When I was reading these chapters and the “Election sermon” I mainly thought of the Calvinist theology of “being elect” as in being saved. That he would prepare to give a sermon on election, march/parade with all the “saints” of the town and then die.

Expand full comment