29 Comments

So I did this bracket with some friends and Dante won, with ATPH as the runner up.

Expand full comment

#4 is a satisfying matchup. Both about appelations.

Expand full comment
author

Also ships

Expand full comment

The Tolstoy vs Tolkein matchup physically hurt. Also, Eustace all the way on the Narnia one

Expand full comment

Well yall are much better closereaders than I. My pick was Charlotte's Web. I lost long ago.

Expand full comment
author

You can keep voting anyway!

Expand full comment
founding

Now that the Tar Heels have lost, I can put some emotional energy into this bracket. Except the thought of having to choose between the opening line of in of Anna and p&p does the same thing to my nerves as the thought of Carolina, having to play Arizona did before today! (I wonder how big the Vin diagram of people having these parallel experiences is!)

Expand full comment
founding

This is impossible.

Expand full comment

Anna K vs Hobbit has me dead

Expand full comment

First couple of rounds, I tried to ignore the book and only focus on "would this line make me want to read the book?" (Actually, I have requested a couple of books from our library simply based on first line in round one!)

By the third round, choosing is really hard. When the choice seems impossible, I fall back on "what line did the non-readers in high school know?" For example, "it was the best of times, it was the worst of times." Everyone quoted that opener - even if they'd never read the book nor knew who Dickens was. It's a great opening line for a reason. I must confess, I graduated high school a long time ago....back when we had chalkboards and overhead projectors....

Expand full comment

Yes! This is exactly how I approached the voting too. Which first line would make me want to read the book? I had to vote for some books I didn't like b/c the first lines were epic.

Expand full comment

The fourth match-up was quite a challenge for me. “Call me Ishmael” is so iconic and direct. I had to ask the opinion of someone who had never heard either and still ended up flipping a coin. I was relieved when Melville won; I suppose it was confirmation to go with my first instinct, even though I felt like I had betrayed Lewis (he’s going to win anyhow).

Expand full comment

Wow, now that we are down to the final eight, my choices are all the underdogs! How interesting!

Expand full comment

I'm with the majority in 2/4. It's hard when I think the better opening line is not from the book I like better. Ah, well. It's fun to see what has made it through.

Expand full comment

The Dickens match up killed me. Aargh! Which one, which one?!?

Expand full comment

Team Eustace!

Expand full comment

How is it that I disagree with so many of you?

Expand full comment

This is getting harder and harder!

Expand full comment

Oh come now. Pride and Prejudice should not win over Dante.

Expand full comment

Why not?

Expand full comment

I think the Dante line is the better line. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Expand full comment

Well, of course I think Dante is "better" overall. But first line only? Still P&P for me.

Expand full comment

I do love Pride and Prejudice, but I had to vote for Dante.

Expand full comment