96 Comments

David, I’ve been meaning to say that the opening paragraph of this is brilliant. I love all the references. That’s some well-crafted writing there.

Expand full comment

This was a lot of fun. It became a family road trip game of "Name that Book" and sparked fun discussions about the books. Thanks for making this.

Expand full comment

My heart soared when I saw Gabriel García Marquez, and then sank when I saw it was the wrong novel! One Hundred Years of Solitude has the best opening line ...

Many years later, as he faced the firing squad, Colonel Aureliano Buendía was to remember that distant afternoon when his father took him to discover ice.

Expand full comment

#18 is way wrong y'all

Expand full comment

This was delightful! Thank you!

Expand full comment

These are solid matchups. But you guys I think Hemingway and Harry Potter are getting shortchanged.

Expand full comment

Matchup 19 was difficult!

Expand full comment

That was difficult!

Expand full comment

No Faulkner openers? The first line of Absalom, Absalom! transports me into that world like a magic carpet every time.

Expand full comment

Lotr vs Madeline-ouch!

Expand full comment

I was waiting for the opening of Dawn Treader the whole way through. Finally on the last vote, I knew I wouldn’t be disappointed. That line gets me every time.

Expand full comment

Matchup 32 hurt somewhat

Expand full comment

Is The Razors Edge any good?

Expand full comment

The brilliance of Pooh shows up in subsequent lines unfortunately not the first!

Expand full comment

I'm curious: with works in translation, how did you pick which version of the first line to use?

Expand full comment

Ahhh Love in the Ruins didn't make it??? That is an awesome first line.

Expand full comment